Star by Star Gaming
[Ban Appeal] Unjustified ban length ban appeal - Printable Version

+- Star by Star Gaming (https://starbystargaming.com)
+-- Forum: Hogwarts RP (https://starbystargaming.com//forumdisplay?fid=10)
+--- Forum: Ban Appeals (https://starbystargaming.com//forumdisplay?fid=15)
+--- Thread: [Ban Appeal] Unjustified ban length ban appeal (//showthread?tid=17493)

Pages: 1 2


Unjustified ban length ban appeal - Joe Mason Moitié - 11-24-2021

To preface - yeah I know i just got off of a 4 week ban for MRDM. I wouldn't appeal this if i thought what i received was completely justified. 


(1) What is your in-game name? - Joe Mason

(2) What is your steam ID (including any banned alt accounts)? - STEAM_0:0:183466692

(3) What is the name of Admin/Staff who banned you? - @@Eloise Sugarplum 


(4) How long were you banned for? - 1 week

(5) Have you been banned on any SBS server before? If so, approximately how many times? - Once in 2019, and another a few weeks ago for MRDM

(6) Have you been banned within the last week? - No

(7) Why were you banned in this instance? (Explain in Detail) - I meant to use stupefy to slap someone away at the door and I unknowingly had avada equipped and killed them. 

(8) Do you think you deserved the ban? - No, at least not to the extent of what I got. I basically did the equivalent of saying half the N word for pressing the wrong button. The person I killed was standing next to us 24/7 just waiting to report someone to get them banned. I immediately apologised once they came back but they just wanted to get me an easy ban. With all this though, I don't blame the staff member, they did a fine job and are on trial so I expect punishment lengths to be formulated differently. 


(9) Why should you be unbanned? - As I said, it was a complete accident. I'm not stupid, I wouldn't blatantly RDM the person target-reporting people under any circumstance, especially not after coming off of a lengthy RDM ban. 

(10) Have you learned your lesson from this ban? - No, it was an accident. 

(11) Provide a Screenshot of the message that appears when you try to join the server: - *on phone will insert later*




For Question 3, you can also tag the Staff Member who banned you so they can receive an immediate notification. To do this, type the: "@" symbol and the name of the staff member after it. If you are not sure who the staff member is on the forums, just list their in-game name and Forum Staff/Server Staff will tag that staff member! 



RE: Unjustified ban length ban appeal - Terrance - 11-24-2021

+1 on full unban I was there after he accidentally killed him he was very apologetic to the person and was a genuine missclick


RE: Unjustified ban length ban appeal - Billy Von Doom - 11-24-2021

Let’s be honest here, no one kills a cctv on purpose. Mistakes do happen.

+1 for a major reduction/unban


RE: Unjustified ban length ban appeal - Liam Saberhagen - 11-24-2021

Better appeal than Emily Broomhandles, seems like an honest mistake that I have made myself and not been banned.
+1 for full unban



RE: Unjustified ban length ban appeal - Misa - 11-24-2021

I do get accidents happen with wrong spells; I still do it myself LOL. I also know the other player had been sticking to those at the door like a leech for a little bit and seemed to be trying to bait things for a couple days now lmao

I don’t rly blame Eloise for the length of ban; though perhaps either a warn or a 1-2 day ban would’ve sufficed (just as you’ve recently come back from a long ban).

+1 for reduction/unban


RE: Unjustified ban length ban appeal - Eloise Sugarplum - 11-24-2021

Hello! I just want to let you know that I have seen this appeal, I am at work right now but when I come home I will send my reasoning for the ban length and such, however I’d love for the community to continue giving their thoughts as well! After I share my reasonings I’ll leave the appeal up for 24 hours before making a decision!


RE: Unjustified ban length ban appeal - Ebony Mason Moitié - 11-24-2021

+1 full unban

Can't even make a mistake now without getting banned.  RIP

[Image: hpVj0D0.jpg]



RE: Unjustified ban length ban appeal - Kenzie Tucan - 11-24-2021

I personally have used the wrong spells as I thought I would have one spell equipped and then I accidentally damage/kill or stupefy someone. It is understandable for the length after the mass rdm ban but accidents do happen.  +1 reduction/unban 


RE: Unjustified ban length ban appeal - [red] Tyr - 11-24-2021

not another shitty ban appeal, and it was a real accident +1

voldehappy voldehappy voldehappy voldehappy voldehappy voldehappy voldehappy voldehappy voldehappy voldehappy


RE: Unjustified ban length ban appeal - Eloise Sugarplum - 11-24-2021

Hi, so the purpose for your ban being a week in the first place was because there was footage of you RDMing another player after having just come back from an MRDM ban. I was advised to give you another 4 week ban length, however I was told that it was up to my discretion whether or not I wanted to give a shorter ban. I didn’t want to ban you for another 4 weeks because it was only 1 student death, but I didn’t want to ban you for too short of a timeframe either since you are coming off of a ban. I will let the community continuing giving their input before I make a decision!