Star by Star Gaming
[Ban Appeal] Rosie Plums Appeal - Printable Version

+- Star by Star Gaming (
+-- Forum: Hogwarts RP (
+--- Forum: Ban Appeals (
+--- Thread: [Ban Appeal] Rosie Plums Appeal (/showthread?tid=17907)

Pages: 1 2

Rosie Plums Appeal - Rosie Plums - 01-13-2022

Your old content:
(1) What is your in-game name? -  Rosie Smelsa-Plums

(2) What is your steam ID (including any banned alt accounts)? -  STEAM_0:1:77469448

(3) What is the name of Admin/Staff who banned you? - Misa

(4) How long were you banned for? - 2 weeks

(5) Have you been banned on any SBS server before? If so, approximately how many times? - No I haven't

(6) Have you been banned within the last week? - Nope

(7) Why were you banned in this instance? (Explain in Detail) - I was in a discord call with a few people playing the game on 5th Jan and I was going around to random people making a jokes with their names. So basically, I told my friends to shout "OOOOOOOO" after I said a joke to someone and we were having a good time. So I approached a dragon called Dragon Cunt and said " Dragon Cunt.... more like F***t Cunt".. and everyone was like "OOOOOO". 
It wasn't until a couple of days later on 7th Jan that I got banned for it.

(8) Do you think you deserved the ban? - Yeah probably, I wasn't really thinking about it at the time when I said it.

(9) Why should you be unbanned? - I honestly just wasn't thinking when I said the word and never second guessed myself at the time. I didn't use the word to purposely offend the guy and he/everyone was laughing along with me. 

(10) Have you learned your lesson from this ban? - Yes of course, I'm gonna think about what I'm saying before i banter with people. I'm sorry to anyone who was offended.

(11) Provide a Screenshot of the message that appears when you try to join the server: - [Image: 96bUf4oZXyWJ1PdJf8PjYrUKZB2vMoAAAAASUVORK5CYII.png]

RE: Rosie Plums Appeal - Ale - 01-13-2022

seems like a pretty unnecessarily long ban, obviously no ill intent

+1 for unban

RE: Rosie Plums Appeal - Rory Martin - 01-13-2022

Honestly Rosie when I heard about it I was very appalled, it just didn’t seem like something you would do

You’re ban appeal is well written out, understanding and apologetic. It’s your first ban and you’re typically a peaceful player. You know what you did was wrong and I have faith that you won’t do it again. You also spent some time on your ban.


RE: Rosie Plums Appeal - Adrian - 01-13-2022

I'm sure Rosie just messed up and meant no harm in any way.

+1 for unban since she served some time already.

RE: Rosie Plums Appeal - Mia Ragno - 01-13-2022

First hate speech offence, owns up to what she did and
waited about half the ban length before appealing.

Ima be +1 for unban

Edit: We usually give warnings for the first offence but I believe
this was from a player report and she was offline when it was tended to
hence why she got a ban rather than the usual warning.

RE: Rosie Plums Appeal - Joe Mason Moitié - 01-13-2022

(01-13-2022, 07:04 PM)Ale Wrote: seems like a pretty unnecessary ban

No it doesn't.

Anyways, served half the ban length and is apologetic.

RE: Rosie Plums Appeal - ERROR: NAME NOT FOUND - 01-13-2022

so this is what got this guy so upset in this topic:

if Rosie has a hatespeech warn on record, then +1 for reduction down to 1 week total to be consistent with other hatespeech reductions

if Rosie does not have a hatespeech warn on record, then +1 to downgrading this ban to a warn and issuing an unban

RE: Rosie Plums Appeal - Amelius Altera - 01-13-2022

Hey Rosie. I was the one who reported Dragon and later you for hate speech. As this was a weird situation I wanted to share the video and offer an explanation to Dragon Cunt as to why the bans weren't initially symmetric.

This is the full clip that covers both you and Dragon's use of hate speech. I don't remember why but I was either AFK or distracted when you said it and didn't tab back in until right around the time when I heard him say it. Either way when I was trimming my initial recording down to the relevant report, I inadvertently cut out your part and only reported his. I didn't think to look back at the original recording until he brought it up in his ban appeal. 

Unlike him you are taking ownership of your actions here and your appeal is genuine. Given that and since it's a first time appeal, I think a reduction makes sense unless you haven't been warned before then a full unban makes even more sense.

+1 for reduction/unban

RE: Rosie Plums Appeal - Robin Hananomi Nefertari - 01-13-2022


Was it wrong? yes

Has she learnt her lesson and already waited 1/2 of the ban already? yes

Based on the clip linked by Amelius, the tone in your voice drastically reduced, practically showing the IMMEDIATE regret in comparison to the other guy who said it.

I would have said +1 for a reduction, but since 1/2 has already been waited out... +1 for complete unban

RE: Rosie Plums Appeal - Ritchie - 01-13-2022

(01-13-2022, 07:04 PM)Ale Wrote: seems like a pretty unnecessary ban, obviously no ill intent

+1 for unban

Like to say it was an unnecessary ban is just a weird one. I do talk to rosie and consider her a friend but this was a no no. Like you did sound angry @@Rosie Plums which I get can get carried away when emotions are around.

I can say if this was a first offence then yeah +1 for reduction.

Just because someone is a friend doesn't mean you have to lie or put a false vote or narrative to the reason for your vote.