Lukas' Ban Appeal

#1
(1) What is your in-game name? - Blink Mlinaric

(2) What is your steam ID (including any banned alt accounts)? - STEAM_0:0:429434457

(3) What is the name of Admin/Staff who banned you? - @@Eloise Sugarplum

(4) How long were you banned for? - 1 week.

(5) Have you been banned on any SBS server before? If so, approximately how many times? - A few.

(6) Have you been banned within the last week? - No.

(7) Why were you banned in this instance? (Explain in Detail) - So Jimmey was running past, i was at the door with a few others, when Jimmey ran past the door and was in the outer CY, i snatched a student and killed him, there was another DF there so i didn't have to use fumos, Eloise claims that there is no "sound" of ropes, so she does not believe I snatched him, you should only really ban players when the evidence is 100% clear, in this situation it was not, it was based off of bugs apparently, not sure what SBS staff are doing nowadays, so technically killing someone with a snatch isn't an rdm, you also couldn't see me after I killed Jimmey because I ran past the door, which would be blocked from how far he was away from the door. So just a bullshit unjust ban that was based.

(8) Do you think you deserved the ban? - No lmao, i didn't RDM, therefore i shouldn't have been banned for RDM?

(9) Why should you be unbanned? - Because i didn't RDM, last time i checked you can kill anyone with a snatch in hand.

(10) Have you learned your lesson from this ban? - Yes.

(11) Provide a Screenshot of the message that appears when you try to join the server: - https://i.imgur.com/jEfuieC.png




For Question 3, you can also tag the Staff Member who banned you so they can receive an immediate notification. To do this, type the: "@" symbol and the name of the staff member after it. If you are not sure who the staff member is on the forums, just list their in-game name and Forum Staff/Server Staff will tag that staff member!
[Image: chapi.png]
Expand Signature

#2
I've seen the video chief; it's just you, a DAR and the Heir of Gryffindor and in the video you just turn and kill a Slytherin Prefect as they're moving away from you and you can clearly be seen with no snatch and such before you happen to walk back into the school. It was very blatant RDM man; don't get me wrong we get on well Lukas but you outright broke a rule on this occasion.

-1 for an unban

[Image: unknown.png]

Edit: You can blatantly see the no ropes attached.

Edit2: I can see how it can appear that the video and such is poor quality but that merely is the screenshot itself, the actual video is in 1080p and is very clear.
 Husband Of Eloise Sugarplum

- Ravenclaw Noble -
- Hogwarts Magician -
- The Auror Enforcer -
Expand Signature

#3
Hello!

Thank you for appealing! So, just to clear a few things up -

Your ban was not because I "did not hear the sound of cuffs" it was because in the video evidence I saw, there is only one of the two people you claimed to be at the door, actually at the door. The second person (who was not there) was the one you claimed to have snatched. I also told you in our sit that I can see both sides of the door through the footage provided by the reporter. I can see (very clearly) the door before and after passing through it. Alongside that, the reporter was using their mic on both sides of the door, so I can see who is around on both sides through there as well. You claimed to have had a snatch, however in the video there was not a rope attached to you in regards to having a snatch, nor were you actively trying to escape the situation. You came out of the doorway, killed the person in question, then went back to the doorway. You have prior *RECENT* bans for RDM, so this situation with the evidence provided, resulted in you getting a 1 week ban for this instance. As I said in our sit, if you or the people you claim were at the door have a clip that disproves what myself and the other staff members saw in the original video, I am more than happy to review and adjust things as necessary. However, with what I saw and what others have saw, I think that this is a just ban. I will leave this up for another day to let the community give their input before I make a final decision, and as always, if you have other clips to disprove what I saw, then please send them in!
Head of the Sugarplum Family
Wife to Misa Nayeli-Sugarplum
Owner of Vengeful Escapist
Dedicated Hufflepuff

YOU'RE WELCOME DAVID!!!
[Image: IMG_2715.png] 

Expand Signature

#4
Even if you did have a snatch (which it doesn't look like you do) surely you're only supposed to kill those that pose a threat to your snatch/trying to save. Jimmey was walking in the other direction and posed no threat to you or your supposed snatch. This is a pretty clear RDM

-1
~Andy Albion Ragno Adareaux Hubbard~

    
    ~Trial Moderator 19th April 2021~
    ~Full Moderator 3rd May 2021~
    ~Resigned 9th Jan 2022~
 

       [Image: 20211031150454_1.jpg?width=1202&height=676]
                                                                                                  
Expand Signature

#5
(12-02-2021, 12:41 PM)I\ve seen the video chief; it's just you, a DAR and the Heir of Gryffindor and in the video you just turn and kill a Slytherin Prefect as they're moving away from you and you can clearly be seen with no snatch and such before you happen to walk back into the school. It was very blatant RDM man; don't get me wrong we get on well Lukas but you outright broke a rule on this occasion. Wrote:
-1 for an unban

[Image: unknown.png]

Edit: You can blatantly see the no ropes attached.
You can’t even tell if there are ropes there or not?, my guy is running gmod in 144p, its literally impossible to see here, don’t think the evidence is 100% like it always should be for bans.

(12-02-2021, 12:58 PM)Andy Albion Wrote: Even if you did have a snatch (which it doesn't look like you do) surely you're only supposed to kill those that pose a threat to your snatch/trying to save. Jimmey was walking in the other direction and posed no threat to you or your supposed snatch. This is a pretty clear RDM

-1

That’s not RDM, the person doesn’t need to be chasing, there have been times where i’ve killed many people just walking, i’ve been told by many staff members in the past that this isn’t RDM.
[Image: chapi.png]
Expand Signature

#6
I watched the video and there was no students around nor were there any killed in the kill feed as the slytherin prefect ran up. As well as there was a light force standing right next to you that you didn't kill, and didn't retreat from after RDMing and revealing yourself with avada.

-1
[Image: arielsig2.png]
[Image: giphy.gif?cid=790b761122c0da1e7b7d93274a...y.gif&ct=g]

[Image: arielsig.png]
Expand Signature

#7
-1 i've seen the video, you just wanted another "silent rdm" for the day thinking no one will report u lmao
wait your time shoeshiner


(also @@Eloise Sugarplum 5000+ respect earned for this incredible ban)
 voldehappy voldehappy voldehappy voldehappy 
[Image: 6B8WBGr.jpg]
Expand Signature

#8
Evidence was clear that there was no one other than Heir of Gryfindor and Dark confidant Spiriod.


1 hour later you started harassing me when I was doing statue RP with Joe. To me this is clear sign of targetted trolling/harrasement.

It's a shame you had to break the rules on someone who cares to report you guys.

Take that 1 week time to cooldown and maybe I'll see you a week later in a better situation.

https://youtu.be/wRLLyiQiTBI heres the vid in question. I bet you must feel real stupid now to lie about it.

[Image: unknown.png]

[Image: asImcd.jpg]

[Image: baboon-laptop.gif]

[Image: unknown.png]
Expand Signature

#9
Sorry man but this is just blatant RDM. 

Also, It is true that you can only kill those who are posing a threat
to your snatch, not just killing anyone you wish. Whoever told you
otherwise is wrong. "4.) You may kill anyone threatening your escape"
is the only written thing related to that in the compendium under DF rouges.
I will see if Jacob can make it more defined for the future. 


-1
Mia Ragno Meadows Dragon Seepleton & whatever Ash's name of the week is
Joined April 9 2019 - VIP April 12 2019 - Master prestige July 12 2019
Trial Mod October 13 2019 - Full Mod October 27 2019 - Resigned February 8 2020
Round 2: Trial Mod November 7 2021 - Full Mod November 21 2021
 Head of the Ragno clan - Most seen family award 2021

hufflepuffPride  PuffPuffPass  hufflepuffPride
Expand Signature

#10
Hello!

I am going to be upfront with you, this appeal is going to be denied. My reasoning behind this is as follows:

Since the video was posted, you can see very clearly that there was no snatch- therefore you have lied in this appeal. Alongside this, there is an overwhelming amount of community members who have commented on this appeal that also believe that you should wait out your ban. During my sit with you over this situation you acted with belligerence and lied in the sit about what happened. On top of the belligerence that you displayed, you also were very insulting towards the staff team as a whole right before I banned you. This appeal came a few minutes after I banned you, and does not seem very genuine. In all honesty, it seems that you leave for a few months then come back only to be toxic. 

I would suggest thinking about how you want to portray yourself on the server during the next week.

Appeal Denied.
Head of the Sugarplum Family
Wife to Misa Nayeli-Sugarplum
Owner of Vengeful Escapist
Dedicated Hufflepuff

YOU'RE WELCOME DAVID!!!
[Image: IMG_2715.png] 

Expand Signature


Forum Jump:

Request Thread Lock


Users browsing this thread:
1 Guest(s)