Staff Feedback Tabs

#1
(1) In-game name & Steam ID (can be obtained by the TAB menu in-game, or by using steamid.xyz)
Relyk Tosser Nightwood STEAM_0:0:241680306
(2)Your suggestion(s):
1. Add a Feedback under the severs. Make it to where the community can give feedback on the staff members that are on that server.


2. Put a Trial Tab under the Feedback Tabs too.

(3) What made you feel that this change was necessary or would make a great addition:

1. In the staff meetings, they have a section on it where they give feedback to their fellow staff. I personally think that is a great idea and lets the staff know where they are doing good and where they need to improve. I feel that the community should be able to have a say in Feedback for the staff of the server. It would also give the Supers the chance to see what the community thinks of the staff Teams not just the staff.

2. While I was on my Trial I staffed regularly with all of 4 or 5 other staff and a few hours with others. This was mainly because half the staff team is on LOA/Low Activity. I failed my trial because they're not being enough staff in my timezone or they just were not on. I say that they should give the Trials 2 weeks then open up a Post on that Trial and for the 3rd week have the community put their feedback in for that Trial. I think that would do great because you would be involving the community in the staff choices instead of just other staff, the community deals with trials more then their fellow staff do.


(4) List what you think (if any) could be possible negatives if your suggestion were to be added:

Honestly, the only negative I can see to this is just people hopping on the forum and saying in a reply "They are a shit mod" and giving no reason. Then again you can always make a format for it so that doesnt happen and if it does you can lock the thread.
  • Joined the Server-03/05/2019
  • Bought VIP-03/18/2019
  • Completed Mr.Steal Your Man 04/29/2019
  • Bought The Time Traveler 08/1/2019
  • Brought the Nightwood's Back 10/22/2019
  • Married Emma Nightwood  10/25/2019

Head of the Nightwoods
Married to @Emma Nightwood Mcguffins
Owner of The Time Traveler
Light Animagus Rouge



Expand Signature
Quote

#2
Huge +1

God forbid we say something to the wrong snowfl--I mean mod, we get screamed at threatened with a kick/ban for staff disrepect or some shit. Having this as an option would ensure that the peoples' voices are heard, and that a fair and accurate response is issued. Too many times have issues been swept under the rug regarding some mods and I feel it's time to let the players have their opinions be heard.
  [Image: 76561198275579397.png][Image: AddFriend.png]


[Image: 5n6yslg.gif]

Son of Bunny and Grayleigh Fuzz

“You’ve been around long enough to know the rules.”

Expand Signature
Quote

#3
(12-05-2019, 08:33 PM)Garbo Bigeye-Fuzz Wrote: Huge +1

God forbid we say something to the wrong snowfl--I mean mod, we get screamed at threatened with a kick/ban for staff disrepect or some shit. Having this as an option would ensure that the peoples' voices are heard, and that a fair and accurate response is issued. Too many times have issues been swept under the rug regarding some mods and I feel it's time to let the players have their opinions be heard.

You literally beat me to it, HUGE +1!
[Image: giphy.gif]
[Image: zwt0N4l.png]
Expand Signature
Quote

#4
Heart 
+1
I feel like a trial tab would be wonderful! There's been a lot of trials where I've seen them do a great job, and a few where I've had to remind them of some unwritten rules it would be nice if the staff team could get to hear what we think of the trials they've picked.
The general staff feedback too would be nice but I would be happy if we only got the trial feedback
Toivon että sä palat helvetissä
Expand Signature
Quote

#5
(12-05-2019, 08:52 PM)Octavia Sangoose-Curze Wrote:
+1
I feel like a trial tab would be wonderful! There's been a lot of trials where I've seen them do a great job, and a few where I've had to remind them of some unwritten rules it would be nice if the staff team could get to hear what we think of the trials they've picked.
The general staff feedback too would be nice but I would be happy if we only got the trial feedback

+1
[Image: giphy.gif]
Ravenclaw Horcrux
The Faceless
"Your ass is grass and I'm going to mow it!"
[Image: 20190302_000700.jpg]
[Image: 4948dbf520d76aa193539c45fa0b08b1.png]

[Image: adcb458bb75e6964f6f1de8b4c377fc3.png]
Expand Signature
Quote

#6
(12-05-2019, 08:18 PM)Relyk Nightwood Wrote: 2. While I was on my Trial I staffed regularly with all of 4 or 5 other staff and a few hours with others. This was mainly because half the staff team is on LOA/Low Activity. I failed my trial because they're not being enough staff in my timezone or they just were not on.

I say that they should give the Trials 2 weeks then open up a Post on that Trial and for the 3rd week have the community put their feedback in for that Trial. I think that would do great because you would be involving the community in the staff choices instead of just other staff, the community deals with trials more then their fellow staff do.

I can understand how you feel about not enough staff being on during /that/ timezone as it stands now.
 Honestly, as soon as it's 9:00 pm AEDT there's a 90% chance it's just
[Image: DlmzI8M.png] GM Gan[Image: 2q8i8J6.png]
[Image: Ju7xAhS.png]
I can see the value in allowing (in the case of trials) the community to, at some point, provide supplementary feedback for the staff team (esp. the manager) to use/consider. However, staff votes (on trials) should always be binding and not community members.

I can also see the value in allowing the community to give their input on other community members, however, I am concerned many may (with deep respect) fail to express their views courteously. I mean, heck, Gamemakers are even told to expect these sorts of people in the thread we're told to read before becoming GMs ('dismiss cruel criticism'). 

Generally, staff are very open to receiving constructive feedback. You can very easily make a thread with the names of the staff you wish to evaluate and just put your paragraph of input next to it.

If there were to be some sort of instrument where each staff could have some sort of additional 'area' on the forums, or some other medium where feedback for staff can be provided, it would:
-Create extra strain on forum staff to monitor (because there's a difference between someone popping off with legitimate criticism like:
'You are super inactive despite holding an important position, I'd like to see more out of my right honorable friend'
 as opposed to stuff that'd have to be removed like
'You elitist fuck inner circle bully gang gunga ginga probed my asshole pls go top yourself' 

Maybe there could be a format? Maybe it could be like a Yelp review you constantly update--- A star rating? I don't know.

At any rate, -1 due to my perceived redundancy/lack of logistical detail of the suggestion.
I personally believe this suggestion can be ignored since any feedback you do have for staff, trial or otherwise can be provided via the feedback section. And it will definitely be brought up, I imagine, by staff that may want to use it.

E,g. (Trial)'s feedback

Mod 1 (during a meeting probably): 'So, my feedback is Blahblahblah, I'd also like to point to this thread made in the Feedback section where 12 community members have praised this moderator for their impeccable activity during a dead timezone'. 
"Hey, Gina can you help us with our weddings?"
[Image: yJMFZhf.png]
Expand Signature
Quote

#7
I like the Idea a lot and thought of suggesting it myself but IG I forgot
but super +1
Quote

#8
+1 this would be a good idea
  Cornelius J Edge  hufflepuffPride 
Expand Signature
Quote

#9
(12-05-2019, 08:52 PM)Octavia Sangoose-Curze Wrote:
+1
I feel like a trial tab would be wonderful! There's been a lot of trials where I've seen them do a great job, and a few where I've had to remind them of some unwritten rules it would be nice if the staff team could get to hear what we think of the trials they've picked.
The general staff feedback too would be nice but I would be happy if we only got the trial feedback
+1 sounds c00l
Friendly gud boi back at it again
[Image: tenor.gif?itemid=14021057]
Owner of Cursed Soul
Expand Signature
Quote

#10
I see both postives and negatives to this. Positives are that it'd allow the community to give their feedback on the staff/new trials, it would allow them to have their say and it would get them involved more but the negatives are that, some players may give negative feedback for some certain staff members due to them warning, kicking or banning them for them breaking the rules. Yes of course that's fine as everyone is entitled to their own opinion but I feel like that'd be unfair as sometimes staff do have to hand out punishments, I know staff (including myself.) are here to guide and help players.

Overall, I don't think it's a bad idea but they are some negatives to this suggestion as well.

With that being said, my vote will be Neutral.
[Image: giphy.gif]

Event Character Name: VADM Reagan
PFC 'Josh' Grange
Hogwarts Moderator
Halo Gamemaker
Joined SBS:
November 18th 2018
Expand Signature
Quote


Forum Jump:


Users browsing this thread:
1 Guest(s)